Skip to content

Felons, Pirates & Broken Men: The Ship That Never Was by Adam Courtenay

May 22, 2018

James Porter was no angel.  He was a good sailor, a fine singer …and a self-serving scoundrel and opportunist.  Sentenced to death in 1822 for stealing beaver furs and silks (later commuted to transportation for life), Porter hated authority and refused to be tamed.  His back bore the scars of 300 floggings, his wrists and legs, the brands of iron chains. Yet, pain and punishment seemed to mean nothing to him.

What Police Prisoner 324 couldn’t accept was servitude and the brutal monotony of everyday life in one of His Majesty’s most notorious penal colonies  – a ‘hell on earth’ – in Van Diemen’s Land.  All he wanted was his freedom.

Finally in 1833, after 10 years as a convict and many failed solo escape attempts, Porter and nine other convicts seized the ship they were building to take them to a new penal settlement at Port Arthur and sailed 6000 miles away to Chile.

This incredible voyage, with only four men who were actual sailors, no navigator and a green-timbered, leaky boat more suited to hugging coastal waters than braving the mountainous seas of three oceans, is one of the greatest escapes in Australia’s colonial history and the subject of Sydney-based writer and journalist, Adam Courtenay’s latest non-fiction book, The Ship That Never Was.

Courtenay, who happens to be the son of one of Australia’s best-loved authors, the late Bryce Courtenay, loves a ripping yarn.  His first book, published in 2013, was Grand Mistresses of the Amazon: The Conquistadors’ First Contact with Warrior Women of the River.

The Ship That Never Was is his fourth adventure into history, and while it may have a less catchy title than the first, it’s no less rollicking a tale. Following his father’s advice that all ‘good books revolve around character’, Courtenay has placed Porter, a small, one-eyed Cockney convict, at the heart of it.

Courtenay first heard of James Porter back in the 1990s when an actor friend played the role of Porter in The Ship That Never Was, a play written by Richard Davey, that’s become Australia’s longest running play, performed nightly in Tasmania from its debut to present day.

‘From that moment on I thought about how to put a book together,’ says Courtenay.

Drawing heavily on the three memoirs written by Porter and a prodigious amount of research, Courtenay immerses readers in Police Prisoner 324’s felonious doings from his earliest days thieving to finance his love of theatre, to running arms off the Peruvian coast, to transportation from England to Van Diemen’s Land where the 21-year-old’s addiction to thrills and schemes plunge him deep and deeper into trouble.

Under the cruel penal code of Governor George Arthur, which saw convicts rise or fall according to their conduct, Porter is whipped, clapped in irons, thrown into a solitary cell and sent to work on a chain gang until he falls the farthest a man can fall: banished to the ends of the earth at Sarah Island where the ‘incorrigible’, irredeemable and depraved’ are abused with impunity and put to work building ships and cutting timber.

It is the anguish and observations contained in Porter’s memoirs that historian Marcus Clarke embellished and wove into his dramatic, fictionalised book, For The Term of His Natural Life, published 50 years ago.  By contrast, Courtenay, shines a historian’s light on the reality of the times be they the plight of the poor in Britain; Governor Arthur’s corruption and treatment of the local Aboriginal people, in whose dispossession and genocide he was complicit; and the dichotomy of Porter’s personality that saw him react with obedience and compliance when shown kindness and respect, and with rebellion and self-sabotage when faced with brutality and monotony.

Courtenay’s popular history takes us beyond the remarkable voyage of Porter and his motley crewmates to Chile (where the men are feted as heroes and and hunted down by the British) and back to Hobart Town where Arthur wants them strung up as ‘pirates, thieves and mutineers’ though  the locals are more inclined to see them as ‘Robin Hoods of the high seas’.

Porter was no saint and his final days make sobering reading. However, Courtenay makes his rollercoaster, incorrigible life into an entertaining read sure to appeal to colonial history buffs, sailing enthusiasts and those who believe in the indomitable endurance of the human spirit.

About the author:

Adam Courtenay is a Sydney-based writer and journalist.  He has enjoyed a long career in newspapers in the UK and Australia and has written three non-fiction books on the Amazon.  His first, Grand Mistresses of the Amazon: The Conquistadors’ First Contact with Warrior Women of the River, was published five years ago when he was 49.  (His father, bestselling novelist Bryce Courtenay, wrote his first book, The Power of One, aged 56). Courtenay Jnr has no plans to write fiction and his fourth book, The Ship That Never Was,  marks him as an exciting new voice in popular history.

Purchase a copy of The Ship That Never Was || Read a sample chapter


  1. Philip Ellison

    Have to tell this reviewer, kindly and gently, that the assertion that Marcus Clarke’s ‘For the Term of His Natural Life’ was published in the ‘Australian Journal’ between 1870 and 1872, appearing as a novel in 1874’, according to Goodreads as sourced 26/5/18. The novel has been published many times since and may well have also been published in 1968 ‘50 years ago’ as asserted by the unattributed author of this review—maybe a robot wrote this piece (WTF? Better Reading; your review writers *must* be acknowledged), but I digress. I think, though, that the point is that Clarke’s classic was written in the 19th century. I guess that the fact checking that could have easily been carried out on this piece was not, which really, in the eyes of this reader, undermines the credentials, integrity and credibility of this review. Mind you, my interest has been piqued and I will be looking out Adam Courtney’s book; it sounds fascinating.

  2. Gary Easthope

    Really enjoyed the book but annoyingly has several errors. Port Arthur is not in the Dentrecasteaux channel, nor is Recherche Bay on the west coast of Tasmania. Interestingly his father put a non existing bridge across the Dentrecasteaux channel in his novel based in Tasmania. Perhaps the author might like to come to Hobart sometime and sail the channel on the square rig brig Lady Nelson run by volunteers.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *