Countless others have rendered their verdict. Now it is your turn.
Russia, 1918: Under direct orders from Vladimir Lenin, Bolshevik secret police herd Anastasia Romanov, along with the entire imperial family, into a damp basement in Siberia, where they face a merciless firing squad. None survive. At least that is what the executioners have always claimed.
Germany, 1920: A young woman bearing an uncanny resemblance to Anastasia Romanov is pulled shivering and senseless from a canal. Refusing to explain her presence in the freezing water or even acknowledge her rescuers, Anna Anderson is taken to the hospital where an examination reveals that her body is riddled with countless horrific scars. When she finally does speak, this frightened, mysterious young woman claims to be the Russian grand duchess. As rumours begin to circulate that the youngest Romanov daughter survived the massacre, old enemies and new threats awaken.
I Was Anastasia unravels the thrilling mystery around Anna Anderson in a tale that is every bit as moving and momentous as it is harrowing and twisted.
Buy a copy of I Was Anastasia here.
Read some great reviews from our Preview readers here:
I absolutely loved I Was Anastasia by Ariel Lawhon. This story is moving, heartbreaking and intriguing. I remember as a child hearing about Anna Anderson, the woman who claimed to be Anastasia Romanov. I have always had a fascination with history and the Russian Imperial Romanov family. I have read books about them in the past and couldn’t believe what those innocent children endured, especially poor little Alexei. This is a cleverly constructed story with dual timelines. Anna Anderson’s story is told in reverse while intersecting the Romanov’s final year of their lives. This is the first book that I have read by Ariel Lawhon, but I bought The Frozen River as I now want to read everything Ariel has written! Sharah, QLD, 5 stars
The book cover says it all! The questions are intriguing – is this Anastasia, or an imposter. The information is well researched and allows the reader to feel all of the bad weather, poor treatment, fear of the unknown, as well as the family dynamics, the faithful family servants. The life of “Anastasia” is also intriguing and shows her to be clever, not showing her hand as she lives her life, but also shows how she is used, often by people she trusts. Did I enjoy reading this novel? Yes. Is the plot line plausible? Yes. The use of modern day science has allowed the idea to be debunked, but for a long time we only had stories and papers to support the idea of Anastasia surviving the family’s murder. Anne, NSW, 5 stars
This book is a wonderful tale of Anna Anderson in her attempts to establish she is Anastasia Romanov from the Romanov dynasty, all of whom were thought to have been executed. The story beautifully travels back and forth in time and demonstrates the life and times of Anastasia and Anna (are they two people or one?). Anna has her supporters but also many detractors who refute she is Anastasia. Lawhon takes us on a journey highlighting the extravagance of royalty against the harsh conditions of ordinary citizens and how fortunes can turn. The revolutions and uprisings saw the Romanov fortune and popularity rapidly diminish. Anna struggles to be recognised as Anastasia Romanov which you learn at the start of the book and as you progress through the book you wax and wane in your belief that she is Anastasia. Throughout the book I was intrigued and compared the book with internet research which made the book even more intriguing. I wondered where Lawhon would end this story, and she did so perfectly. I thoroughly enjoyed this book from start to finish. I can highly recommend. Lyn, QLD, 5 stars
I have always held an interest in the Russian Royal Family and the story that Anastasia survived when the family was exterminated. I really delighted in this story that is based upon that and follows the story of young Anastasia and then the battle of Anna Anderson to try and prove that she was in fact Anastasia. What an amazing life she lead with even members of Royalty backing her claim and the guy who had a crush on her when she was a young girl. Surely someone who knew her so well then and spent almost every day with her would know if Anna Anderson was an imposter? Even if you know the true outcome of the real life claim as I do, this story had me engrossed and not wanting to put the book down. Its frustrating when life interrupts reading time. So wonderfully written that I know I will return to this book and reread time and again. This is one to add to your Christmas shopping list. Annamaree, QLD, 5 stars
This book was released in the US in 2018, but is about to be released in Australia. The story begins with a warning from Anna Anderson (or Franziska Schanzkowska); or is it Anastasia Romanov? Which do you think it is? You are invited to find out in this book. I’ve always been intrigued by the Anastasia Romanov story, but never knew much about her, her family or Anna Anderson and her claim to be the surviving Anastasia of Russian royalty. I was really looking forward to learn a lot! Ariel Lawhon has crafted an excellent novel from the facts provided from both Anna’s supporters and detractors. I loved how the dual stories telescoped together to the vital moments of the story from the beginning and end. I did struggle with some of the journey; it sometimes felt tedious and fact-heavy. However, the story overall was gripping as it drew inexorably toward the conclusion. If you are intrigued by the Romanovs and the beginnings of the Soviet Revolutions, this is the book for you! Christine, VIC, 5 stars
This is an enthralling piece of historical fiction. Or is it dramatised non-fiction? Either way, it’s a fascinating and intelligently told story of a decades long mystery, which I’m still not convinced has been fully solved. The author’s vast amount of research is evident and it brings the parallel storylines of the Romanovs and Anna Anderson vividly, and authentically, to life. The story is told in two time-lines: one chronologically, the other in reverse. The further I got through the book I could understand why the author presented it in this way, but it did test my ability to recall what went before, or after! Despite the likability (or not) of certain characters, the deaths of the Romanovs and the possibility that Anastasia survived but was denied her existence is a tragic and true story. Alternatively, this is a story of a woman so damaged by her past, whatever that may have been, that she has entered into a full-blown delusion. Either scenario is so heart-wrenching that personal feelings about likability seem petty and irrelevant. Highly recommended both for lovers of history and mystery. Jill, NSW, 5 stars
Very few would be unaware of Anna Anderson, the “Unbekannt Fraülein” who it was claimed was Anastasia, the surviving daughter of the Russian Tsar Nicholas whose entire family was believed murdered in 1918. Ariel Lawhon has woven together the stories of Anna and Anastasia in interesting, non contiguous timelines ….we see how times and places link to each other and are allowed to wonder ourselves ….could it possibly be true? When I was a child there was no certainty as there is now and the way we are shown the cast of supporters and detractors, the faithful retainers and brutal soldiers allows our imaginations to wonder what would we have thought or believed In that particular time period and locations where the flotsam and jetsam of post WW1, highborn and low, were trying to find their place in a new society. I was fascinated and intrigued by the detail and description and felt so much empathy for “Anna” whose story is no less tragic than that of Anastasia. Lesley, QLD, 5 stars
Since I watched the Ingrid Bergman movie as a child, I’ve believed that Anastasia Romanov had somehow survived her family’s assassination. Even now, after DNA testing, I want to believe. There have been many books (and other movies) based on Anna/Anastasia’s life, but Lawhon does a fantastic job at presenting the details in a uniquely compelling manner. Anastasia’s point of view is presented in chronological order, starting in 1917. The story of Anna Anderson, who claimed to be Anastasia, is told in reverse date order, starting in her later life in 1970. I found both sections fascinating. I was pretty naive on the history of the Romanovs and I really did become engrossed. Anna’s life, after she revealed herself to the public as the youngest daughter of the Tsar, was an odd one, where she relied on the support of a plethora of wealthy acquaintances, who all seemed to not truly know her, despite what they said and thought. Lawhon’s pacing and tension were on point. The final few scenes of the book, although expected, were shocking. And just a tip, you must also read the author’s notes at the end. They form an important part of the book. Lee-ann, QLD, 5 stars
I was Anastasia by Ariel Lawhon brings to life the story of Anna who claimed to be the daughter of the last tsar of Russia and the only survivor of the tsar’s family’s execution in 1918. I found this book thoroughly engaging. I was Anastasia makes for eventful reading with fascinating, but also harrowing, accounts of the last months of the Russian Romanov royal family. Recounts of the ups and downs of Anna’s adult life, dependent on various sympathetic royalists whose intentions aren’t always clear, also kept me turning pages right to the surprise ending. Chapters about Anna’s adult life move backwards in time and are interspersed with events of the months leading to the family’s execution. Whilst this structure serves well to reveal Anna’s story little by little, it’s a bit confusing without paying attention to chapter headings that specify timeframe. All in all, I was Anastasia provides a fascinating insight into the brutal Russian Revolution and an era that saw the end of aristocratic privilege in much of the world, whilst weaving an engaging story around an enigmatic character. Barbara, NSW, 5 stars
Beautifully written, it is sometimes hard to remember you are not reading a biography instead of a novel. The life that the Romanov family lived was forever changed when they fell from favour and were later executed. When a young women claimed to be Anastasia Romanov the world was divided. I was really invested the story and wanted it to be true. Christina, NSW, 5 stars
A fascinating and intriguing historical mystery that kept me enthralled right up to the end. I thoroughly enjoyed the book and the author’s crafting of the story. Knowing that the story and characters were based on actual events made it more poignant and tragic. It has made me want to read more from Ariel Lawhon. Denise, TAS, 5 stars
I started this book with only a vague prior knowledge of this story. As someone with no abiding affection for royal families in general, this was something that was never likely to be on my radar screen. But I was seduced by the challenge on the cover blurb – Romanov or fraudster? Who doesn’t like to solve a puzzle? I found the book quite fascinating. My thoughts on the Romanov vs fraudster conundrum waxed and waned as the book progressed, and as the story’s complexities were set out. I found myself rather liking the author’s approach in moving about in time and relating large parts of story backwards. It kept me on my toes as to the chronology of the key story elements. What stays with me most strongly is the precarious nature of Anna/Anastasia’s life across many decades, and the devotion shown by her true Romanov believers through repeated setbacks. Their work in keeping her safe and protected against the best efforts of her detractors. All in all it was a book that was easy to read and one I very much enjoyed. I particularly enjoyed the concluding chapter which lined up nicely with my final thinking. Ian, ACT, 5 stars
Ariel poses the question and with the use of historical documents and her own interpretation of the facts, the reader is taken on a journey as a detective trying to unravel truth from fiction as to the assertion of Anna Anderson that she was truly Anastasia Romanov. The book is also a comment about immense wealth and deprivation – is a family deserving of being rich or should they have it all taken away so that they can experience the same feelings of being poor as the rest of the population of the country. A book that is hard to put down. However, the question remains; has Ariel solved the mystery? Cheryl, VIC, 5 stars
Thoroughy enjoyed. A good read. Marew, TAS, 5 stars
Great book from the first page to the last. I was so going on the journey with her to the very last sentence. Beautifully written and just heartbreaking Liz, NSW, 5 stars
I Was Anastasia is an incredibly captivating novel that dragged me in, albeit with more than a few frustrations. The novel reads in a unique way, with two stories being told, one reading backwards, whilst the other reads forwards, intersecting yet never quite meeting. The further I read the more secrets were revealed, yet I found that the uncovering often led to more questions, encouraging me to read further. My frustrations with the story were due to the introduction of characters after their interactions as I’d have to read back to see how they fit in the story. This was definitely a new way to read a story. Jodie, WA, 5 stars
I really enjoyed I Was Anastasia by Ariel Lawhon. An historical novel about Anna Anderson or as she preferred to be called Anastasia Romanov. During reading we learn the facts of the imprisonment of the Russian Royal family, and I found it fascinating to get an insight into the characters of Anastasia, her older sisters and her sickly brother. It expains how Anna appeared with Amnesia and scarring over her body leading to her claims of Anastasia’s identity. Her friend Gleb appears prominently, a friend from Anastasia’s childhood and now a friend of Anna Anderson. Gillian, QLD, 5 stars
Absolutely beautifully written story about Anastasia Romanov or is she an imposter. Loved it from the very beginning. Could not stop reading. Had to know what happened, I did cry in parts. But what a great journey this book takes you on. Elizabeth, NSW, 5 stars
I would highly recommend I was Anastasia by Ariel Lawhon to lovers of historical fiction! The dual time line woven throughout the book is compelling and keeps you engaged in Anastasia’s life and Anna Anderson’s! The authors creative ability to write Anastasia story line forward in time and Anna’s back in time and eventually merging is very clever! Significant research and historical facts keep the reader immersed in a book where we all know the outcome of the Romanov family. Absolutely loved the ending, just perfect ! Ilona, VIC, 5 stars
From page one what a gripping story, totally engrossed. Highly recommend if you are after a thriller. Maree, TAS, 5 stars
Ariel Lawhon has done it again. I Was Anastasia is a brilliant read. A psychological thriller and historical fiction rolled into one. One part of the story is the young Anastasia, under house arrest, moving each day towards the events at Ekaterinburg. The dread and suspense grow whether the reader is already aware of what happened to the Romanov family or not. The other part is the story of Anna Anderson. She challenges the reader to make up their own mind about whether she is Anastasia or an imposter. Anna’s story is told backwards in time, drawing us closer and closer to the young Anastasia, taking the reader on a whirlwind ride. I simply loved it. Alice, NSW, 5 stars
From the brutal death of her family in Russia 1918 to Germany 1920 where she jumps off a bridge, Grand Duchess Anastasia Nikolaevna of Russia, daughter of Nikolai Alexandrovich Romanov, second Tsar of Russia and Alexandra Feodorovna, granddaughter of Queen Victoria and Empress Consort of Russia is trying to prove that she is the last remaining Romanov. The one and only that survived the brutal murder of her family. She is given false documents under the name of Anna Anderson, so that she can escape the country without detection. It is coming up to 10 years since that dreadful day and now the other Romanov relatives are trying to stake a claim to the Romanov fortune. She is then pushed from pillar to post all over the world, Russia, Germany, France, New York and more, to try and prove that she is really Anastasia Romonov. But is she really Grand Duchess Anastasia or has she deceived everyone. This was a really great read and definitely a page turner. Sue A, NSW, 5 stars
I really enjoyed this book. I have not read any books about Anastasia or the Tsar’s, but knew they had been executed. I was totally wanting it to be true that Anastasia had survived. Very cleverly written even if I did find reading backwards a little weird. Who was Anna Anderson? How did she come to have those stab wounds and bullet scars? I enjoyed the prose. Enough description of people and places but not overdone. I really enjoyed the Author’s Note at the end. Her explanation and thoughts or Royalty and privileged lives. How amazing that this book showed up uninvited and pre-empted all her plans – demanding to be written. I am glad it did and that she yielded. I will definitely read more by this author. Joy, VIC, 5 stars
The age old question did Anastasia Romanov die with her family by the Bolsheviks in 1918. The possibility of her living provides an engrossing historical fiction novel in ‘I Was Anastasia’ which is full of drama, romance, and mystery. Anna Anderson claims to be Anastasia and has “friends” who entertain and fund her life to attempt to prove that she is indeed Anastasia and heiress to the dynasty. We learn about the lead up to the Romanov family’s execution and of Anastasia’s (Anna’s) escape in the book. The book is a journey into Russian history mixed with the fictional story of Anna and I could not put it down. An engrossing read Karyn, ACT, 5 stars
I found the book “I was Anastasia” by Ariel Lawhon extremely fascinating as I did know that the Russian Czar and his family had all been shot dead in 1918. there was a rumour that the youngest daughter Anastasia had somehow survived. In this book Anastasia becomes Anna Anderson and although there is quite a bit of switching backwards and forwards in years and events its a very interesting story which has been well researched historically and one can indeed believe that the story is true. It is a book which is hard to put down and you are always wondering what is going to happen next and I thoroughly recommend it especially for anyone who enjoys history and mystery Katrina, QLD, 5 stars
Knowing very little of the Russian revolution, nothing of the Anna Anderson impostor story and not generally a historical fiction fan, I did not have the highest of expectations that this book would appeal to me. But it is beautifully written, quite captivating and full of suspense – leaving me thinking of it days after I’d finished the final page. While it took a bit to get into at the start, it became increasingly difficult to put down. Danielle, QLD, 4 stars
Who is Anna Anderson? Was she Anastasia from the Romanov Family? This is something Ariel Lawhon leaves you wondering by the end of the book and lets you make the decision if she was. As soon as I started reading the book the historical event became familiar. It’s been ages since I read anything about Russian History or watched something on a screen, especially the fall of the Romanov family. Reading ‘I Was Anastasia’ got me chatting with my teenage son about the fall of the Romanov family and what had happened. This made the history about Anastasia fascinating and kept me reading. While reading and talking to my son about the story he filled me in, he is also reading the book at the moment and has made a comment that the author has done her research quite well. I found the different type of storytelling that the author has presented this book difficult to follow at the beginning but then it just flowed into place. I think anyone that enjoys historical fiction will enjoy ‘I Was Anastasia’. It has me interested to read more books on the period and of course it’s a bonus when you can discuss the story with your teenage son and get him interested into picking up a book to read that mum has read. Maria, SA, 4 stars
To believe or not to believe is the question! Starting in the present and slowly rolling back to the past this royal intimate saga is slowly unraveled through the mind of Anastasia, one of the daughters of the Tsar Romanov. Whatever the outcome of this known historical story the reader is left questioning the survival and validity of this young women who claims to be Anastasia. Intriguing, sometimes confusing and also convincing this detailed account of the life of the Romanov family during the Russian revolution brings a large portion of callous and pitiless Bolsheviks characters along into this story. It is definitely worth immersing yourself in this brutal and harrowing drama. Della, VIC, 4 stars
When I was a kid I read about Anastasia in Strange Stories, Amazing Facts (a great big book of interesting and intriguing information from Reader’s Digest) & had numerous discussions re Anna Anderson (& if she was in fact Anastasia) with my dad. Of course we didn’t have all the forensic DNA analysis available in those days that we do now, so no wonder people were never sure if she was the real deal… Anyway, ‘I Was Anastasia’ is as equally interesting as my early Reader’s Digest introduction to “Anna” was & whether you know (or think you know) the truth, well worth a read! Ayesha, NSW, 4 stars
Ariel Lawhon has written an intriguing account from history with her book I Was Anastasia. She has described events that took place in Russia during the wars in the early 1900’s, including the revolution. Graphic detail allows the reader to gain a more accurate account of events back then. The characters are each portrayed by their actions. Russian soldiers and those with rank showed little or no regard towards their captives. They were despised and hated by those suffering from their brutality. There were a few exceptions not comfortable with witnessing the suffering of others whilst having to obey orders. The plot for this story is based on true events as well as fiction. It relates to how the Russian Tzar and military officers handled situations during the wars. The mistakes made resulted in an unimaginable number of lives being lost. The welfare of the soldiers and citizens was not considered important by those in charge. It is hard to read about the atrocities committed on innocent people. There are many twists and turns in this fascinating story of the misfortunes befalling the Romanov family. The reader is kept guessing up until the end. Cherylene, QLD, 4 stars
Years ago I read a biography about Anna Anderson. She was the most plausible contender among several who’ve claimed to be Anastasia, the youngest daughter of the Russian royal family. Although she was eventually exposed as an imposter doubts remained until DNA testing finally confirmed all the family had been murdered in 1918. Most people who pick up this book therefore will know Anna is indeed ‘a fraud and a liar’, but maybe like me are intrigued to know how well Lawhon handles the stories of both Anna and Anastasia. The answer for me is incredibly well. This is a skilfully written and compelling novel that almost persuades the reader to believe fiction is fact. Some will find the book’s structure annoying. It’s only when the storylines of Anna and Anastasia finally converge that readers can fully appreciate and understand Lawhon’s decision to write the book the way she did. It’s a clever approach but may not appeal to readers who prefer more traditional linear timelines. I thoroughly enjoyed this well-researched and thought-provoking historical novel. Anne, TAS, 4 stars
The mystery surrounding the Russian princess Anastasia Romanov and what happened to her and her family during the Bolshevik Revolution is one that has captivated many imaginations, inspiring both books and movies. The author has researched the many different accounts of what occurred during the time and has chosen the life of Anna Anderson to explore the possible scenarios and to bring them to life. It is a thought provoking, though difficult read, as the book skips around timelines. It is important to read the chapter titles carefully in order to keep track. This was a deliberate decision by the author as a means to convey the mental struggles which the main character exhibited. Anna is portrayed as both a fierce, while flawed character, who in real life had both staunch supporters and strong opponents of her story. While the truth of her story has now been realized, having had little previous knowledge of the events surrounding her life, I was kept guessing as to the truth of her claims until the end of the book. This made for a captivating read for me. Whether or not you know much about the Romanov story, this is a great historical read if you persevere. Karina, QLD, 4 stars
I love historical fiction. I enjoyed the Russian history. Unfortunately the timeline was confusing. I would still recommend this book if you enjoy reading about Russian history. Debbie, VIC, 4 stars
This is a book I would not normally have read but glad I stuck with it. It is a mystery from start to finish and when you think you’ve worked it out you are left wandering if you really have worked it out. Anna, TAS, 4 stars
A mystery of Anna Anderson, claiming to be Anastasia Romanov a Russian grand duchess whose family was executed in Siberia in 1918. I don’t read much historical fiction but this had me intrigued from the very beginning. It is well written, I can’t say I had a favourite character they all had many varied roles in the book. The atrocities of wars especially in today’s world made me think why can’t we live in peace. The atrocities continue! A book I would recommend and will certainly read other novels of Ariel Lawson. Helen, TAS, 4 stars
An amazing story and very well written. I was fascinated from the beginning. For a while, the structure of the book kind of threw me. We have two timelines, one of them that moves forward from 1917, and other that moves backward, until they merge. An interesting concept! For a while it bothered me that I had to think so hard, moving backwards all the time with the one timeline, but I did get used to it, and when I reached the end I could see why it had to be that way. The ending was such a surprise, which at first made me mad and then drew my deepest and most ardent admiration for this author and what she did. Judi, NSW, 4 stars
Within the very first chapter I was entranced. This is a very new approach to the old mystery of what happened to the grand duchess Anastasia Romanov? The story takes us on a journey through time, switching between several decades. It travels back to the time of the Russian revolution and winds an interesting path for the reader, visiting historical events, human suffering, emotional challenges and ultimately surprising answers to long needed questions. This was an enjoyable read that kept me turning the pages with enthusiasm. Jacqui, QLD, 4 stars
This was a captivating blend of historical fiction and mystery which is loosely based on a true story. The narrative alternates between Anastasia’s former life as a Russian grand duchess and Anna’s life. I found this book engaging and thought-provoking as the depth of each character developed. I found myself backtracking to keep up with the alternating timelines but would definitely recommend to lovers of historical fiction and to those who (like myself) remain intrigued by the story behind this infamous icon. Justine, NSW, 4 stars
I Was Anastasia is the story of Anastasia Romanov, the last Russian Czars’ daughter. Was Anastasia executed along with her family during the Bolshevik Revolution or did she miraculously survive? The story is told chronologically in reverse and initially confusing. Even though the outcome has not been resolved, the historical content and characters kept me enthralled. Nektaria, VIC, 4 stars
This well written book is a roller coaster of emotions and reality, A story of strength and resilience. Kate, QLD, 4 stars
Survivor or fraud? This question was asked for decades once Anna Anderson came forward claiming to be Anastasia Romanov, Grand Duchess and youngest daughter of Tsar Nicholas II of Russia. In an age prior to DNA testing and facial recognition this claim captured the imagination of many, infuriated others and offered hope of a miraculous account of survival against the odds. This novel imaginatively recounts the historical events surrounding the fall of the Romanov empire that saw the privileged family imprisoned and, finally, executed. The novel humanises the tragic characters of history and provides an intriguing account, not only of the family’s final days, but of the emergence of Anna Anderson and the cost of becoming Princess Anastasia. This is a non-linear story that requires some concentration to keep the chronology clear but it is a structure that really adds to the element of suspense and mystery. As the novel progresses there is a real sense of dread but also of hope for a happy ending. This is a haunting historical novel about one of the most intriguing characters of the twentieth century. Heidi, SA, 4 stars
While the story itself was an enjoyable read about a less than wonderful event in history and while I don’t mind stories that time jump I found it annoying to go backwards then go backwards a little bit further when it could have just gone there to start with Gai, NSW, 4 stars
‘I Was Anastasia’ had me captivated from the very first chapter. The dual timelines were creatively crafted and as a reader, I was invested in both Anastasia and Anna’s stories. Ariel Lawhon’s dedication to researching this topic was evident in her writing and her excellent delivery made for compelling reading. I had little knowledge of this topic before reading the book and I found myself inspired to research and learn more about the people and places mentioned. This was a very emotional and moving historical fiction. Kylie, NSW, 4 stars
I Was Anastasia by American author Ariel Lawhon is a gripping historical story that tells the tale of in Anna Anderson’s fifty-year battle to be recognised as Anastasia Romanov. Russia, July 17, 1918: Under direct orders from Vladimir Lenin, Bolshevik secret police force Anastasia Romanov, along with her entire imperial family and execute them by firing squad. No one survived that is until a claim of a young woman bearing an uncanny resemblance to Anastasia Romanov is pulled from a canal. Is it really her? The balance in bringing together historical events and fiction was well done, creating a compelling portrayal of Anna Anderson and her claims. I enjoyed the nuances of the dialogue, which offered a good flavour of the period but never got so overdone as to become difficult to follow. The story knocked me sideways with its action and suspense. It was also thought-provoking because it left me with questions. The characters were superb, and I felt the depth and emotions in them. The author has done a tremendous job in researching the lives of Anna and Anastasia. I recommend reading Lawhon’s note at the end which details her research and what led her to write this novel. Everyone should read this book, especially lovers of historical stories. Melissa, SA, 4 stars
I enjoy Ariel Lawhon’s books, and this was no exception. The non-linear timeline had me confused at times, but certainly added interest to the story. It begins in 1970 with Anna Anderson waiting for the outcome of her appeal in a German court case proving that she is Anastasia Romanov. She has spent many years pursuing her claim with the help of Gleb who knew Anastasia as a child in Russia. The story is told in such a way that you get bite sized pieces of her life throughout, including her childhood, the time of the families arrest and imprisonment in 1917 -18, and the many stages of her life since then. It is very easy to become invested in her quest, even though you sometimes wonder if she is fully invested. The clues leading to the outcome are subtle and leave the reader puzzled and unsure and I’m not sure whether I enjoyed the last chapter or was upset by it. You’ll have to read it for yourself. Catherine, QLD, 4 stars
Ariel’s writing makes me feel like I’m living in the era of Russia, 1918 and Germany 1920. I’m engaged from beginning till the end. This novel makes you feel all emotions, how going from having everything to nothing affects your personality and how everyone responds differently. It is based on horrific true events that happened with the Russian imperial family. I loved this book, especially as it jumps between time periods, keeps you engaged and holds your interest. There are two sides to every story and I recommend you read this novel to find out the truth about Anastasia Romanov beloved daughter, Russian grand Duchess. Nicole West, QLD, 4 stars
This is an interesting book based on past events and stories of the Romanov’s and the story of one Anna Anderson and is she who she says she is? This is an intriguing story to say the least and one I was really looking forward to reading. Told in two voices this story went back and forth with both stories having their strengths and weaknesses. The pace of the story works well but the two stories sometimes didn’t flow as well as I would have liked making it at times harder to read. Also the research by the author is well done and the author’s notes always bring a story together as the notes in this book did. This book told not one but two stories and it did feel like the two women were not at all alike which makes you think. And I like a book that makes me think. I enjoyed this book and found it quite compelling even though it was not a perfect read. There was enough in it to keep me reading and wondering. Donna, TAS, 4 stars
I Was Anastasia is not your regular who-done-it mystery but rather a who-is-it. I really enjoyed the non-linear way the story was told. It was unexpected, like a written piece of impressionistic art. The further back you step, the more you read, the more it all comes together. I love Ariel Lawhorn’s style of writing, it’s effortless to read and the story just flows right off the page. I may have actually gasped out loud a time or two during the reading of this book. I really appreciated the authors note at the end, it added perspective. Belinda, VIC, 4 stars
The death of the Russian royal family in July 1918 is undoubtedly one of the seminal events of the twentieth century. Sending shock waves around the world it also spawned a fascinating mystery that left its mark on popular culture. Were all the Romanovs killed that day, or did one, the Grand Duchess Anastasia, in fact survive? This well-researched novel follows a dual narrative: the first recounts the royal family’s last months while the second details the life of Anna Anderson, the mysterious woman fished out of a Berlin canal, who later claimed to be Anastasia, heir to the Romanov title and fortune. Equal part mystery and historical fiction, the novel alternates between the two storylines. Interestingly, the Romanov narrative is relayed in chronological order while Anna’s journey is presented in reverse chronological order, with both stories intersecting in the novel’s dramatic conclusion. While I initially found the reverse timeline a little confusing, as a literary tool it proved to be an inspired choice. The author takes the reader on a journey into the past, skilfully revealing details and building suspense until the inevitable, but still startling, conclusion. Highly recommended. Kendall, NSW, 4 stars
What an astonishing story this is. Told from the POV of Anna we are drawn into her story and the possibility that she is Anastasia Romanov, a Grand Duchess of Russia. Anna is reliant on benefactors her whole life, and some of these people are sympathetic to her cause and others are looking to use her for their own standing. With only one or two true friends, Anna is constantly wary and does not trust easily. The story is told by looking back on all the events in Anna’s life. From her times in mental institutions, being feted over by those looking to exploit her and of course her time as part of the world of the Romanovs. The build up to the execution of the Romanovs is tense and unsettling and I was quite emotional when the event occurred. Ariel Lawhon knows how to bring history alive and this is a beautifully written story that evokes many emotions. Michele, NSW, 4 stars
Being a history fan and one who has always loved the story of the Russian Imperial family and Anastasia, this story has not let me down. Lawhon has written a beautiful moving story that had my emotions changing from feeling love, to anger and sadness as we travel forward and back with Anastasia and then Anna (as she is known) through different periods of their lives. We read about the women who is small but very fierce and strong willed, who continues to survive even though life has been harsh and cruel to her. The feeling of both love and safety from her friends and family, and the hatred even more from their enemies. From Russia, through Germany, to France and America it has us wondering if this is the real Anastasia, or her imposter. Tania, QLD, 4 stars
I’ve always loved the story of Anastasia! I was totally invested in both of the Storylines! Very well written, it sucked you in right from the beginning. Both storylines were captivating and made you want to know more. Well researched and I felt I learned a thing or two. Karina, NSW, 4 stars
A very interesting read about a story and family from history. This story brought to life a part of history that stills seems to be a mystery to most. A Royal Romanov Family, WW1 and the deaths of this royal family. But did one family member survive and live on to tell the tale or is this person an imposter? This is a book that has been well researched and well written. At times it was a bit hard to follow along and I did have some confusion while reading it but I took my time and took it all in so in the end I felt I hadn’t missed anything. Plenty of mystery and pieces of the puzzle to put together to bring it all to a close. Donna, TAS, 3 stars
Most of us, even as adults, love a fairytale with a happy ending. The assassination of Tsar Nicholas II and the rest of the Romanov family in Ekaterinburg, Russia by the Bolsheviks and the fact that the mass grave with their bodies (although two were missing) was not discovered until 1991 gave rise, particularly in the intervening period, to the hope that perhaps all, or at least some, of the Romanov family had escaped. When a woman (Anna Anderson) claimed for years to be Anastasia Romanov, there were many people who believed her, bearing in mind that DNA testing did not become used until the 70s and 80s. Lawhon’s book is work of a historical fiction, well researched, with a little poetic licence used to reduce the number of characters in order to make it less confusing. However, the structure of the book is an alternating asynchronous two-person storyline told in the first and third person (Anastasia’s begins in 1917 going forwards and Anna’s told backwards from 1970). Some people might find that rather confusing as the author wishes us, the reader, to decide whether Anna really is Anastasia or mentally ill and perhaps a rather cunning opportunist. Pamela, VIC, 3 stars
‘I Was Anastasia’ is a big tale, telling a story in a non-linear, unpredictable sequence of chapters, that spans decades. It’s quite a commitment at 400 pages. Russian history in the Romanov era, Germany during the war and beyond, New York in the 20s and 30s are the backdrop for Anastasia’s / Anna’s life. In the preface the author actually states ‘If you want the truth, you must pay attention. Do not daydream or drift off.’ I quite enjoyed it, but I had to work hard. Cheryl, NSW, 3 stars
“I Was Anastasia” by Ariel Lawhon is an interesting take on a classic story that has gripped the world for years. There has always been mystery and rumours surrounding what happened to Anastasia after the death of her family and we have all heard of people over the years claiming to be her. This book takes that idea and explores the lengths people will go to in order to convince others of a particular identity. If you have an interest in the story and mystery of Anastasia you will enjoy this read. Emma, NSW, 3 stars
Ariel Lawson’s novel investigates Anna Anderson’s quest to be recognised as the Russian Grand Duchess Anastasia Romanov. The story is told with the use of a dual timeline with Anna Anderson’s account being told backwards which for me was difficult to follow. I found Anastasia’s timeline more captivating and readers interested in Russian history will be fascinated with this retelling of the events leading up to the tragic fate of this family. Throughout the reader is compelled to question is Anna really Anastasia. The author’s conclusion is uniquely delivered and may come as a surprise ending for some. Regina, NSW, 3 stars
Ariel Lawhon’s “I Was Anastasia” is a captivating historical novel exploring Anna Anderson’s claim to be Anastasia Romanov. Alternating between the Romanovs’ final days in 1918 and Anna’s decades-long fight for recognition, the book is rich in historical detail and well-researched. While I learned a lot, the dual timeline structure—Anastasia’s story moving forward and Anna’s backward—was occasionally confusing. Despite this, the novel remained gripping, with a satisfying ending that tied the timelines together beautifully. Ally, TAS, 3 stars
I Was Anastasia by Ariel Lawhon is a meticulously researched historical novel that delves into the mysterious life of Anna Anderson, who claimed to be Anastasia Romanov. The story alternates between Anastasia’s harrowing final days during the Russian Revolution and Anna’s 50-year battle to prove her identity. Lawhon employs a unique dual timeline structure—Anastasia’s story moving forward and Anna’s told backward—which leads to their eventual convergence. Though the novel is rich in detail and historical accuracy, this nonlinear narrative can be difficult to follow. While Anastasia’s story is compelling, the backward structure of Anna’s timeline can feel disorienting and slow at times. Nevertheless, Lawhon succeeds in building suspense, especially in the Romanov chapters, where the tension builds as the family faces their tragic fate. For fans of Romanov history, this book offers a thought-provoking exploration of identity, memory, and the allure of Anastasia’s legend. Despite the challenging format, I Was Anastasia is a captivating read that invites readers to ponder one of the 20th century’s greatest mysteries. Tyson, TAS, 3 stars
This is such an interesting story! It is told in split timelines which I usually love, but I did find Anna’s timeline to be less enjoyable and a bit disjointed as it’s told in reverse. I did however enjoy learning about this little bit of history that I knew nothing of previously. Kate, QLD, 3 stars
I was Anastasia by Ariel Lawhon was an interesting read. The story of the last days of the Romanov family is told through the eyes of the Grand Duchess, Anastasia, while we meet Anna an elderly lady who claims to be Anastasia. Anna’s reminisces take us back through her life, and her struggles to prove that she is, indeed, the Grand Duchess. I usually love fiction based on historical events, and this book was certainly well researched, and very well written, but this time, I really struggled with the timeline. The story was cleverly written, but I found Anna’s story became a little confusing, as I was constantly checking back and forth, trying to work out where the story was up to. Anastasia’s story was fascinating. I liked the first person narration, and the straightforward timeline made it easier to follow. I was intrigued to read the Author’s Note, and, for me, it took the story to a whole new level. Ariel Lawhon warns us not to read this before reading the book. It’s at the back of the book for very good reason. A well written, well researched book! Three stars for me this time. Jude, NSW, 3 stars
An epic tale of royalty, history , hope and despair. The tale of the Romanov family, Russian Royalty. This story takes you back and forth through decades of intrigue, is it the real Anastasia or an imposter. The truth is not revealed until the last pages. The story takes takes time to tell, a lot of thought and attention to detail. If historical fiction is your genre you will thoroughly enjoy this book. Julie, QLD, 3 stars
I’ve always been fascinated by the story of whether Anastasia Romanov survived the massacre that killed the Romanov family, as we now know she did not survive but this story almost has you believing that she did, took me a bit to get into it but once I did I was hooked. Michelle, VIC, 3 stars
I have very mixed feelings about this book. I enjoyed the historical aspect, was very interesting to learn about Anastasia Romanov and her family and the atrocities they endured. I thought the 2 alternating stories and the mystery surrounding the characters was a great idea but I don’t think it was executed very well. I didn’t mind the story being told backwards but there was too many back and forth with the dates which made it very confusing at times. Worth a read but not an easy read and not a book you can put down and come back to every couple of days. Karen, NSW, 3 stars
This book was not in my wheelhouse but I gave it a go. I found it difficult to read having a sense of the true history and no mystery. Jonathan, NSW, 2 stars
This book was not for me. The chapters were all over the place so the timeline was hard to follow. I found it difficult to read having a sense of the true history and so for me there was no mystery. Michelle, NSW, 2 stars
I found this book hard to read. It jumped all over the place. Some parts were good, some not at all. Not to my preference Michelle, QLD, 2 stars
Thank you, Better Reading Australia, for the opportunity to read the mystery of Anastasia / Anna. I found this to be a bit of a slow read and the continuous switch from the dual POVs (Anna’s past to Anastasia’s present) made it difficult to follow and grasp where the story was flowing. It was not my ideal read although, if you are a historical fiction fan then I am sure you would appreciate the research and details which helped to define the story line. Jess, QLD, 2 stars
I was looking forward to getting to this novel and moving it up my reading list but unfortunately, I was disappointed and, at times frustrated. I enjoyed learning more about the Romanovs and their demise. These were my favourite parts. The character of Anna, however, was one of a schemer and an enigma to me. I think it is generally a well-crafted novel but the dual timeline was a hot mess. I typically enjoy this literary feature. Kate Morton is a master of it. This time I was often confused and constantly flipping backwards and forwards to keep track. Yes, it felt like ‘juggling chainsaws’! Susan, VIC, 2 stars
I really struggled with this book to the point where I just couldn’t finish it – I gave up half way through. This is almost unheard of for me. But there we have it. I absolutely love historical novels such as this however, the constant jumping through different timelines was confusing and haphazard. At times I had no idea what year I was in – or what week or month. The characters were not only extremely hard to understand but I had to question who they were and why they were even in the story as they had no impact. After 170 pages of reading Anastasia’s story I didn’t even really “know” her. I felt like she was just a stranger in a book. I realised there were two points of view but unfortunate Anastasia’s story was way too long for me to persist with the story. Diane, SA, 1 star
Leave a Reply