‘Is that what you want to do? Peer into my soul and capture my flaws, for all to see?’
As World War II draws to a close, Australian society is still deeply conservative. Homosexuality is illegal and the scourge of Modernism is infecting Australian art.
When William Dobell paints a portrait of lover and fellow artist Joshua Smith, he is awarded Australia’s most prestigious art prize. However, Dobell’s celebration is cut short after a protest is lodged by his competitors, who claim the painting is a caricature. Both artist and sitter soon find themselves in the glare of the spotlight when a court case to determine the matter turns into a public spectacle.
Bill and Joshua’s relationship is put under pressure and at risk of being exposed as they are caught in a world where they must choose between love and art: between acceptance and exile.
Read some great reviews from our Preview readers here:
An extraordinary story of love, passion, art, expression, and loss. Based on the true story of Dobell and Smith, Kim E Anderson weaves a wonderful narrative of public intrigue and private tumult into one of the best novels of the decade. I loved it! Shannan, NSW, 5 Stars
The Prize is a queer historical fiction novel that takes place in conservative Australia. The story is a fictionalised depiction of events based on the scandal surrounding the 1943 Archibald Prize. When William Dobell paints a portrait of artist Joshua Smith, he wins the Archibald Prize, the highest award for Australian art. The friendship and love portrayed between artists William and Joshua was stunning yet heartbreaking. The characters and their personalities were well-written and events flowed brilliantly. A beautifully written novel that encapsulates a part of Australia’s history that I was unaware of prior to reading this story. The Prize is a touching, informative and highly emotional story. I look forward to reading more historical works from this author as well as future novels featuring queerness within Australia. Brittany, VIC, 5 Stars
This book is a fictional account based on the facts of the court case regarding the Archibald Prize of 1943 – won by William Dobell with a portrait of Joshua Smith, fellow artist and lover. It brings the characters to life and gives background to the period during World War 2 and the prejudices of that time. I had seen the painting but I did not know the story of the controversy about it and the lives of the artists involved. It made me look at 1940s in Sydney and the paintings that were in the Archibald Prize of 1943 to see the difference between William Dobell’s portrait of Joshua Smith and the others – the traditionists and “modernists”. This is an easy book to read and gives background and context to the painting and the friendship of William Dobell and Joshua Smith. Christine, VIC, 5 Stars
A gripping read that takes the reader back to a time most of us can only imagine, having to contend with the societal prejudice so many experienced. I couldn’t put the book down, the characters all became so real and the storytelling was brilliant. Terin, QLD, 5 Stars
The Prize explores the racy world of fellow artists vying for the coveted Archibald Prize. A story of relationships and acceptance of sexual taboos of the 1940s, an artist’s world bound by the rules of society and wishing to push old-school portraiture into the modern world of artistry. Kim E Anderson’s novel explored genres I’m not familiar with but kept me intrigued and wanting to know more of the life of infamous artist Sir William Dobell, an enigma ahead of his times. Jenny, QLD, 5 Stars
I really enjoy The Prize. Such a beautiful story of real-life events with a fictional twist that did justice to the storyline. Rene, WA, 5 Stars
I can remember as a secondary art student putting together a project about Australian artist William Dobell. I had read about the 1943 controversy in which his portrait of friend and fellow artist Joshua Smith was described as a hideous caricature. Anderson brilliantly brings this story to life, with her description of the budding relationship between Bill and Joshua, always at risk of being stifled by the latter’s controlling mother Louisa. With his painting, Dobell had captured a determined spirit within Joshua’s gangly body, but the sensationalism that accompanied the court case about whether the painting was portrait or caricature meant that this admirable characteristic became cold stubbornness. It is a compelling story of the conservative Sydney society of the time, both regarding modernism in art, and forbidden relationships. I thoroughly enjoyed this book, though it is an extremely sad story. Helen, SA, 5 Stars
I enjoyed reading a story based on true events. The controversial Archibald Prize in 1943 broke the friendship between William Dobell (Bill), the winner, and fellow artist, Joshua Smith. Society’s judgement on how perfect a portrait must be accurate eliminated the art element from the painter’s point of view. What seems like something to celebrate has turned out to be a tragedy. Love, hate, and jealousy is part of history and time may not always heal the wound. Reading this novel, I time-traveled to Wangi and Kings Cross during WWII. Margaret, NSW, 5 Stars
Such an interesting book. The war is coming to an end when William Dobell enters the Archibald Prize. In 1943 being gay is still illegal. William paints a portrait of Joshua who is also an artist but is William’s lover. The reader is taken through a court case where the public are outraged by this scandal. Deborah, NSW, 5 Stars
What a great read! Going into this book, I had no idea what the Archibald was about, but after finishing the book I have a greater understanding and learnt some history behind it all. So many “read between the lines” moments in this book. The writer was so respectful in how she wrote of the relationship between Smith and Dobell. I thoroughly enjoyed this book and highly recommend it. Jen, NSW, 5 Stars
My family has an arty background. My parents owned an Art Gallery in Auckland. So, I was really looking forward to reading The Prize. This was a great love story between two men. Showing how intolerant the world was regarding homosexuality. To a certain extent, some still are intolerant. It also shows that what is art to one, isn’t “Art” to another; “Art is Subjective”. I loved this book, and I hope to read more by this author. Bridget, VIC, 5 Stars
Life in Australia. even Sydney where this story is based, in the 1940s was very conservative. People who thought ‘outside the box’ or didn’t conform to set standards were certainly on the outer. You sensed trouble when two artists (same sex) formed a strong relationship including love. This was kept quiet as one of the artists still lived at home with his parents who were Christians. Both artists, along with many others, decided to enter the famous Archibald Prize for portrait painting in 1943. One of them was the winner with his portrait of his friend; the other one was runner-up. A prolonged court case took place with art experts explaining the art of portrait painting. Along with constant pressure from the media, this took a toll on both artists both physically and mentally, and had an effect on their relationship. This novel was based on true events and I would encourage you to read it. Jill, VIC, 5 Stars
Very entertaining book which was easy to read and comprehend. Surprise ending. Would recommend. Kathleen, NSW, 5 Stars
Australia in 1943 hasn’t quite caught up with the rest of the world and is quite reserved in its thinking, particularly in its views on sexuality and what constitutes good art. It is in this environment that artist William Dobell and fellow artist Joshua Smith enter the Archibald Prize. What follows is a controversy that rocks the Australian art community and questions the conservatism of all Australians. Kim Anderson has done a masterful job of taking the facts of this event and fleshing them out to create a very believable interpretation of what may have taken place in the lives of the artists, their families, and friends. This book tugs at our heartstrings and leaves us with an overwhelming sympathy for the characters and how their lives played out. Karina, QLD, 4 Stars
The fictionalised story is based on one of Australia’s influential artists (Dobell) and the Archibald Prize-winning painting that caused much scandal, a court case, and a broken relationship with his friend (and portrait subject). It was an entertaining read with a glimpse of post-war art-life in Sydney – the court case was quoted closely to the real court case, and whilst parts were dull, other parts were more comedic than I would have expected. A good read for a wet weekend. And you might learn something new along the way. Indigo, NSW, 4 Stars
The Prize is a fascinating read that describes a part of Australian history I knew nothing about. I enjoyed the way the reader learns about the main characters and their personalities. The background about the Archibald Prize is very relevant to how the story pans out. Although a novel based on true events, I felt the author captured the characteristics of the main two artists and their families and friends very well. The court case scenes were long, but there was a lot to cover. The relationship between the artists is a special one and is explored beautifully. The outcome is known from the start, so not a spoiler, but I found it very sad that their friendship was destroyed by the reaction of other artists, the public, and some of their friends to the winning portrait. A really great debut novel from the author. Toni, QLD, 4 Stars
The Prize offers readers a rare insight into the art world and the prestigious Archibald Prize. Kim E. Anderson cleverly crafts this historical fiction to perfection as we delve into Australian society in the 40s where tradition is challenged and scandal ensues. At times, this well-researched story feels quite personal, as we walk alongside Bill and Joshua and the harrowing experiences they face and the decisions they must make. I would recommend this novel to lovers of art and history alike. Maria, NSW, 4 Stars
I actually loved reading this. The start was a little slow, but then when I got to know the characters I really enjoyed the story and how all the events unfolded. I found the story very well told, and felt very moved by how everything played out and how both main characters took everything to heart and both suffered in their own ways after the painting. A recommendation: look up an image of the actual painting for some more context. Eltica, QLD, 4 Stars
This is a fascinating look at a bizarre court case. The art establishment and large portions of the public took offense at the representation of a portrait subject, on behalf of that subject. The sensationalism of the proceedings caused a devastating and permanent fallout. Relationships are central to this story, which simultaneously paints an intriguing portrait of Sydney society, mid-WWII. Times have certainly changed, but we still have some way to go until we show truly equal respect for all loving relationships. Perhaps books like this will help grow the empathy required. Heidi, VIC, 4 Stars
A brilliant Australian historical read. Australia in the 1940s was very different to the Australia of today. It is sobering to remember how conservative Australia was then. A very thought-provoking book. Gail, WA, 4 Stars
This is my favourite type of historical novel – one where the facts seem so unlikely that you’re compelled to track the back story down any number of internet rabbit warrens the minute you manage to finish and put the book down. The novel brings alive a small slice of Sydney artistic society at a very particular time, with the personal and professional passions of the two protagonists set against a backdrop of social and artistic conservatism. The controversy at the heart of the novel seems ludicrous today – but is based on fact, which makes other unfamiliar aspects of society at the time seem more believable. The sense of tenderness and fear with which the relationship between the two artists is described drew me into their lives, and left me feeling sorry for what might have been if these two talented men had had the chance to be born 50 years later. Jen, TAS, 4 Stars
The Prize, a book that I would probably not have picked up to read, allowed me to be quite immersed in the story. It allowed me to enhance my knowledge and understanding of the art world, particularly the 1943 Archibald competition and winner. I felt compelled to research what the winning art piece actually looked like. A great visual picture (of the prize-winning portrait) was described by the author, but curiosity got the better of me and I wanted to see what all the drama was about! Along with the scandal of the awarding of the Archibald Prize, the author has excellently portrayed the relationship of the artists, William (Bill) Dobell and Joshua (Josh) Smith, which during this era was very much a prohibited relationship. This book was a rewarding read into an historical event very few (including myself) would have known about. Karen, VIC, 4 Stars
Although the 1943 controversy surrounding the Archibald Prize is well known, Kim E Anderson takes the reader into the personal lives and emotions of the two at the centre of attention – the artist, Wiliam Dobell, and the subject, Joshua Smith. Anderson shows aspects of life in Sydney during World War II when the war almost seems at a distance. That art could remove the war from the front pages of the papers and that lengthy queues could form to view the painting and offer their opinion reinforces for the reader how controversy can destroy lives. Indeed, it is the personal lives of Bill and Joshua that involve the reader. The distress that both suffer is moving and life-altering. The contrast between their loving time together early in the novel, especially at Wangi, and their complete alienation as a result of the controversy, is heartbreaking. The courtroom scenes with “expert” witness opinions are truly humiliating for Joshua and upsetting for Bill, whose defence of his artistic intent intrigues the reader. The Prize is well worth reading for insights into both the art world and personal relationships. Frances, NSW, 4 Stars
I thought The Prize was a well-written book. It gave enough information without being too over the top in regards to art lingo, making it easy to read and understand. Katrina, TAS, 4 Stars
I had no previous knowledge of the scandal that surrounded the 1943 Archibald Prize. I loved being able to google and see what the painting looked like for myself. I found this story that is based on real events to be so very interesting and it amazed me that such a drama could be made over a painting. It’s sad that there was such judgement against gay couples at the time, as if the artist had been able to openly say he was in love with his subject that might have ended the trial a lot swifter. I really enjoy being able to learn about real events as I read and even though the story is not 100% to real events it is still so very educational about the 1943 Archibald Prize, the court case and peoples attitudes of the time even to the extent that pregnant woman were advised to stay away and to not view the painting unless the shock brought on labour. A brilliant long weekend read for those that like to read something different and be educated into the bargain. Annamaree, QLD, 4 Stars
A very sad story of how public perception and media attention can skew and ultimately destroy things and perhaps people. I looked up an image of the portrait of Mr Joshua Smith to see what all the fuss was about and have decided that we all need to make up our own minds about whether or not it should be considered a true portrait. One thing I am sure of, though, is that the legal system shouldn’t have the last say. We all bring our own perspective to viewing each work. I am hopeful that we have come a long way since 1943. Heidi, VIC, 4 Stars
The Prize is a beautifully written novel that takes the reader on a journey, discovering the “ins” and “outs” of the coveted Archibald Prize. When Bill’s entry is highly scrutinised and relationships are criticised, it leaves you wondering about the beauty of friendship, relationships, and mateship. Sharnee, QLD, 4 Stars
I’m so grateful to Better Reading for giving me the opportunity to preview this book, one I probably would never have chosen to read myself given that I knew nothing about this interesting piece of Australian history. The Prize explores the 1943 Archibald controversy. The book depicted the downfall and heartbreak of two central characters who are at the centre of a grueling court case. Once in love, their relationship is ripped apart when art and law collide. Thanks to beautiful storytelling, I really felt their heartache and anguish. I connected and empathised with both characters and was hoping for a happy ending. This story is Aussie at heart and begs the question, who decides what art is? Chloe, VIC, 4 Stars
I did not expect to enjoy this book as much as I did. I was so invested in the characters and their story. I felt myself getting angry and really digesting the story. This was a great way to tell this true story. Daneka, QLD, 4 Stars
This book provided an insight into the art world, a world that I know nothing about. The relationship between Bill and Joshua was beautifully depicted, and the courtroom events were captured very well. Ultimately, the story was a heartbreaking one. The effect of the court case on Joshua, and perhaps to a lesser extent Bill, was well articulated. The book led me to do some of my own research, which magnified my sadness for Joshua. I’d be curious now to read the only interview that he granted following the court case. Joanne, QLD, 4 Stars
This book is about a true story of the art completion called the “Archibald Prize”. It tells the story of two artist friends who are also dealing with their homosexual relationship in a time when this is illegal; they then compete against each other in “The Prize” and consequently this blows their friendship apart, changing their lives forever. Set in Sydney during the Second World War, the book also touches on life for these friends in wartime Australia and the work they do to help the country, their life living in Sydney, and the surrounding suburbs, including Kingscross. An easy read and an interesting topic of “The Prize”, even though I am not personally interested in art. I would recommend this book to anyone. Crystal, TAS, 4 Stars
A fascinating insight into a moment in the history of the Archibald Prize and the conservative values of the time. I wonder what would be made of some of the recent winners against the same backdrop? The book provides an emotional look into the impact of the drama surrounding the key protagonists involved in 1943 and those who supported them. I became immersed in this well-researched story and would recommend it, not only to those interested in art, but to anyone who is interested in people and their stories. Annette, SA, 4 Stars
An interesting take on a story I was not previously aware of. Overall an enjoyable read with interesting insight into the art world. Vanessa, NSW, 3 Stars
Based on real-life events, The Prize tells the story of the controversial 1943 Archibald Prize win by William Dobell, which divided the art world and broke up a friendship. Rebecca, NSW, 3 Stars
Two artist friends Bill Dobell and Joshua Smith enter the Archibald in 1943. Joshua’s was a traditional portrait and Bill’s had elements of caricature. Bill won with his controversial painting. Interfering friends decide to appeal the decision and lost. In the process, they ruined a great friendship and achieved nothing, although widened the scope of interpretation of what a traditional portrait could be. I enjoyed this book (based on a true story), although it felt like it took a while to get to the real story. I also found it very interesting. Gloria, SA, 3 Stars
I enjoyed the opportunity to review The Prize by Kim E. Anderson, thank you! I have huge admiration for anyone who actually knuckles down and actually writes a book and then gets it published, an enormous achievement. While The Prize recounts a very interesting time in Australia’s art history, sadly I wasn’t really gripped by the storytelling, rather more by the historical events. So, if you want to read about an interesting time in our history, I can recommend The Prize. Julie, SA, 3 Stars
An interesting premise. I had no idea about the controversy around the 1943 Archibald Prize. I enjoyed checking out the portraits in question. Overall the book was interesting but felt more like a factual account of events rather than a novel. I would have liked a little more substance to the story to keep me more engaged. Laura, QLD, 2 Stars
I found this book a very frustrating read to be quite honest. I kept hoping to be able to like one of the characters or at least identify with them but I read the entire book in vain. What I did enjoy was the description of familiar settings; having lived in both Sydney and Newcastle I found the author captured the differences between the two cities well. Frances, NSW, 1 Star
Leave a Reply