Skip to content

‘He came roaring at me with a knife’: a review of Waiting for Elijah by Kate Wild

May 29, 2018

It’s Tuesday 2 June, 2009, and in an inconspicuous laneway in Armidale, NSW, 24-year-old Elijah Holcombe is shot dead by an undercover police officer, Senior Constable Andrew Rich. Elijah, a philosophy and psychology student at Sydney University, has had no contact with the police until that fateful day when Rich shoots him claiming ‘he came roaring at me with a knife’.

The shooting provokes intense public scrutiny. Eye witnesses come forward to claim police officer Rich did not need to shoot Elijah. The Holcombe family come forward to describe their son as a sweet-natured young man, a talented musician working part time to support his studies. They also reveal that in the previous twelve months, Elijah has been treated for a mental illness.

For weeks leading to his death, Elijah appears to be suffering intense paranoia and delusions. By the eve of the shooting, Elijah’s family becomes aware their son’s mental health is rapidly deteriorating. Close to midnight, he telephones them claiming his wife, Allison, is plotting with his room-mate – a member of the Turkish mafia, he says — to murder him. He is disoriented and afraid.

Could this explain why the next day Elijah runs from the police officer – because he’s caught in the depths of hallucinatory uncertainty?

This tragic, real life shooting of a mentally ill young man is the starting point of Waiting For Elijah, a true crime book by triple Walkley Award-winning journalist, Kate Wild.

Wild’s book, written after a six-year investigation, is a forensic dissection of the crime scene with equal parts compassion and a hawk-eye for detail. Kate Wild makes it clear that she believes the tragedy did not need to happen, and what unfolds beneath the atmospheric retelling of the shooting is a deeper discussion into how society perceives and reacts towards mental illness.

It must be mentioned that Wild is an excellent writer, brandishing all the narrative techniques wielded by a novelist. There’s not a dry eye moment, nor lapses into technical/legal lingo. Written with dialogue, scene recreation, and present tense passages, Waiting for Elijah is a totally immersive treat for non-fiction and fiction lovers alike.

Any contemplation of true crime in the Australian writing scene can’t forgo mentioning Helen Garner as the primary point of comparison. Wild remains true to fly-on-the-wall journalism and self-omission — that is, until she becomes actively involved in the story, pursuing leads and family members and police officers to unearth the blood-stained bones of the matter. We recommend Waiting for Elijah unreservedly.

About the author

Kate Wild is an investigative journalist whose work with distinguished teams in the ABC has been recognised with three Walkley awards and a Logie. Her reports from Darwin, where she lived from 2010 to 2016, laid the groundwork for a Four Corners story on juvenile detention that prompted the calling of a Royal Commission.

Like Elijah Holcombe, Kate grew up in country New South Wales; she now lives and works in Sydney. Waiting For Elijah is her first book.

Purchase a copy of Waiting for Elijah.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *