• Review

Your Preview Verdict: The Whisky Widow by Karen Brooks

Buy a copy of The Whisky Widow here.

Read some great reviews from our Preview readers here:

An historic romantic novel that keeps you on the edge of your seat. A fascinating story that has a mother and daughter looking for a new start in life, only to move across country and find a new home, a purpose and love all at the same time. Great to see everything works out for them. Dale, VIC, 5 stars

How can you go wrong in a book when it has two of my favourite things in life. Whisky and historical fiction and also a bonus is written by one of my favourite authors. Fell in love with Karen Brooks’ writing when I first read ‘Good wife of Bath’. She must do so much research into her topics that when she produces a book you feel like you are right there and enjoying the adventure she gives you. From the highs and the lows that her female characters go through. Greer MacAlister has gone through so much in Whisky Widow while also having a deaf daughter to look after. I enjoyed reading all the drama, suspense, surprises, emotions and emotions her characters found along the way. It would have been so hard for Greer to pack up and move with her daughter to the highlands of Scotland soon after her husband passed away to work for someone she has just met. Moving into a remote village where strangers were not welcomed because the locals thought they were there to spy and report them about the illegal trade of whisky making. ‘Whiskey Widow’ is a must read book for anyone that loves historical fiction with strong females. I definitely recommend this read to my friends especially if they drink a whisky or two while reading. Maria, SA, 5 stars

Karen Brooks has written a wonderful novel called The Whisky Widow. Her characters are believable and lovable and you want to go on their journey with them. Greer and Fen show such bravery whilst undergoing a dangerous world of smugglers whilst in an era when living in the Scottish Highlands was a struggle! It is well written and a joy to read! Rhonda, QLD, 5 stars

The Whiskey Widow is a stunningly told story of resilience both on a personal and community level. This book had me on the edge of my seat many times and was often a case of ‘just one more chapter’ as I got caught up in the drama, suspense and intrigue. There were twists I never saw coming but the suspense was broken up with lighter humouress moments and a touch of romance. One of my favourite parts of the book was the interweaving of Christian beliefs with the traditional Scottish superstitions and supernatural beliefs. This was especially interesting as I am half Scottish and have encountered many superstitions through family. This book was an absolute joy to read and one that will stay with me for a long time. Definitely one of my top reads of 2025! Leanne, VIC, 5 stars

This gripping historical adventure is a must read! Set in scenic bonnie Scotland during the 1700’s, you become a part of the land in this well researched story. Following an emotional and twisting story line, we see themes of whisky making, friendship and the mother-daughter relationship, and we are exposed to a little told side of Scotland. Highly recommend for anyone with a love of or link to Scotland! Kate, VIC, 5 stars

Set in the undeniable home of whisky production the rugged Scottish Highlands, The Whisky Widow is a story of courage, resilience, grit and risk for our intrepid central characters Greer and her deaf daughter Fen. The plot involves success, betrayal and disaster along with intrigue and family friction in the Highland Clan setting. From being shunned and mistrusted as ‘incomers’ to slowly gaining the trust of the Highland villagers, it is a tale that immerses the reader in the lives of Highlanders in the 1780’s and the history of whisky making. The historical detail is rich and well researched and the whisky making fascinating. Another resounding success for Karen Brooks. Rita, WA, 5 stars

Such an interesting and enjoyable book, that takes you back in time. You live through the hardships and struggles of people back in time. Sometimes you wonder how they survived. Karen Brooks has done a splendid job of taking you back to a time of wonder at the hardiness of people who came before us. Jan, VIC, 5 stars

An thoroughly enjoyable story of whisky , love and finding your home in the unexpected. Joanna, VIC, 5 stars

This novel was a delight to read, and just what the doctor ordered. I found myself eagerly anticipating when I’d be able to get back and read another chapter or two. Lovers of Diana Gabaldon’s Outlander will love this novel also, as readers are thrust back into the Scottish Highlands, with all the politics and intrigue that go along with it. Characters that you can’t help but empathise with and events that will continually keep you guessing. A great read! Angie, VIC, 5 stars

I loved everything about The Whisky Widow – the characters, the story, and the history. Up until now I was quite unaware of the role whisky played in Scottish history, or the history of whisky itself. Karen’s wonderful descriptions made it very easy to immerse myself in Greer McAllister’s world, and the Scottish Highlands of the late 1700s. This novel was filled with just about everything, love, prejudice, violence, tragedy, triumph, and the odd nail-biting situation. A fabulous book that was difficult to put down. Chrissie, WA, 5 stars

The Whiskey Widow is about more than the fascinating history of whiskey in the Scottish Highlands. It is about Strength, courage and family. Greer is faced with inconceivable odds when she leaves a difficult home life, travelling to her husband’s last known place of employment, only to discover that not only had he been neglectful in every way, he had also lead a double life with a new family. Finding herself with nowhere to go, Greer persuades Tam Gordon to take her on as housekeeper. Upon arriving Greer is faced with the reality that this may be the most foolish mistake she has made yet. I love the feisty and brave character of Greer. She doesn’t give up in the face of a town prejudiced against her, but works to build a life for her daughter, Fen. She has to overcome her own prejudices against a people who are brewing illegal whiskey, as well as gain the trust of a people leery of ‘incomers’. Karen Brooks has researched this book well and the characters really come alive and sparkle on the page. They are real. You can hear their voices! This is truly an enjoyable read, with adventure on each turn of the page! Sarah, TAS, 5 stars

I was hooked right from the start! The Whisky Widow transports you to the Scottish Highlands, as Greer McAllister and her young daughter carve out a new life and try to win over the suspicious locals. Karen Brooks’ historical novel explores being an outsider, relying on instincts and inner strengths, and unexpectedly finding love. I loved the connections between the female characters and their resilience in the unforgiving environment. This was a really enjoyable read and I would highly recommend! Maddie, ACT, 5 stars

I absolutely adored The Whisky Widow. It was such an engaging read & gave me some insight into what life may have been like for my grandmother’s Scot ancestors (who emigrated all together as a big family group on one ship – & now I have an idea as to why they may have all come together at the same time). This book gave real insight into the conditions in Scotland at that time. A really enlightening read! Ayesha, NSW, 5 stars

What a fantastic read! Whether or not you’re a fan of historical fiction, I recommend that you give The Whisky Widow a red hot go! Greer MacAlister finds herself in a pile of trouble when her difficult husband leaves her in more trouble when he dies. With her deaf daughter Fen, she works at making a new life in a highland village suspicious of people like her. A different language, unusual customs, distrusting locals are only a few of the hurdles Greer must overcome – and then murder, smuggling and danger take centre stage. Highly recommended! Lisa, NSW, 5 stars

From the lovely hand drawn map at the beginning to the very last page, this book had me enthralled. It is a meticulously researched depiction of what it would have been like to live in the Scottish Highlands during the 1780s. The importance of whisky to the Highlanders, not just to drink, but to use to trade and bribe was very interesting. Also the detail in which they distilled it to make the perfect spirit. It also explores the rivalry between the Highlanders, Lowlanders and Sassenach. It is a story of rich characters. Greer is an admirable woman and I loved the relationship she had with her daughter Fen who is deaf. She is fiercely protective of her refusing to allow her disability to define her or hold her back. On the contrary, the use of sign language and willingness of the others to be taught, not only allowed Fen to be enveloped by the community but also added another armour to the villages artillery. Tam takes Greer by surprise, with his gentlemanly and non conformist ways. It was lovely to see their relationship develop. This is a wonderfully romantic adventure written with heart. I also enjoyed the use of the Gaelic language and appreciated the glossary at the back of the book. 4.8 stars Sue, VIC, 5 stars

Having Scottish Heritage, I had heard of the Highland Clearances; however this tale brought them home to me in a personal way, through the story of Greer and Tamhas. It is all at once a smuggling adventure, a tale of distrust and final acceptance, of heroism and betrayal and a beautiful love story. I loved the evocative descriptions of the highlands and the harshness of the lives led by these simple folk during difficult times. Strongly recommend The Whisky Widow for lovers of historical fiction and Karen Brooks in particular. Kirsten, WA, 5 stars

Karen Brooks can write a story you can really lose yourself in! The Whiskey Widow has reignited my love of historical fiction. In every glass of whiskey is an act of rebellion and what a rebel Greer is, she is a strong , courageous, inspirational woman who had me wanting the best for her all the way. This book was unexpectedly emotion, witty and informative. I loved every page. Melanie, WA, 5 stars

This well written book kept me entertained from the beginning to the end. Betrayed by her deceased husband and forced to move to a very small village in the Scottish Highlands, I could feel the desperation felt by Greer about her situation and Fen’s problems but also her joy at small things like that illicit whisky tastes better than the official one they sold at the tavern in Edinburgh. The mistrust of outsiders is so big that even after 20years in the Village, you are still called an outsider. I enjoyed Reverend Father Son’s use of the f word (and the unknown spelling) and confess, I had to look up a couple of words, I did not encounter before. It is an easy read with lots of interesting facts, I really enjoyed. Yes, some parts were predictable, but that did not matter to me. Sandra, NSW, 5 stars

Brilliant book. I would say this is the best book I have read this year, kept me interested from the start. Twists and turns especially towards the end was incredible. Karen Brooks is a fantastic story teller, setting the scene in the late 1700’s in Scotland with fascinating characters with a mix of drama, love and resilience. A throughly researched book makes you believe this story is 100% true, but Karen explains at the end how she came about to write this book which is a great bonus read. Only thing is I wish I knew there was a glossary at the end for the gaelic words used in the book before I started to read it. I could not wait to keep reading and looked forward to the end, which is full of surprises, twists and turns that were not expected. Now I wish I could get a continuation of the story and it would make an amazing film too. Set in a time when things were tough and choices had to be made to survive, a truly brilliant read. Linda, VIC, 5 stars

What a wonderful read! I picked this up because I loved The Good Wife of Bath, but I think I loved this one even more! Such loveable, diverse characters, a strong sense of place, a fascinating insight into the history of whiskey and its role in Scottish life, not to mention the rest of the living and political conditions at the time, and even some mystery and adventure! I feel like I’ve literally lived in that little Scottish village in the 1700s beside them. A full five stars and then some. Emily, WA, 5 stars

With 450+ pages The Whisky Widow is a book you can dive into and stay awhile. I really enjoyed following Greer MacAlister and her daughter Fen and at times wondered how on earth they were going to survive. I loved the very clever twists and turns and really enjoyed how the book shined a light on the use of finger talking which we now refer to as sign language. With Fen losing the sense of hearing when she was a small child finger talking is a big part of her life and when she starts to teach hearing people this skill it proves very handy to all in the community. This book was an education into the Illegal Whisky trade in Scotland and how important it was to keep entire communities alive. This is a book that is so very worth your time. I felt quite attached to Greer and felt in some way that I was reading her account of her life. There is romance but its not a mushy type of story. There is Murder and Mystery. This book was perfection. Perhaps Karen Brooks could do a Book Two about Fen and her future life. Annamaree, QLD, 5 stars

This is my favourite historical novel! It was enthralling with amazing characters in combinations of amazing, formidable and awful, beautiful yet harsh countryside and an extreme desire to improve one’s life and overcome adversity! Lisa, WA, 5 stars

The Whisky Widow by Karen Brooks is a richly woven, emotionally powerful tale set in the Scottish Highlands in 1780. A Lowland woman, now the widow of a despised excise man, finds herself and her daughter, in a remote whisky smuggling village. With determination and strength, she overcomes suspicion and hostility to become a well-loved and respected member of the community. When tragedy strikes, she steps forward, further demonstrating her leadership and commitment. The Whisky Widow is a powerful and atmospheric novel of love, courage, murder, and hard-won belonging. Highly recommended. Charlene, WA, 5 stars

The Whisky Widow is a great book. It transports the reader to life in the Scottish Highlands in the late nineteenth century. The descriptive writing takes the reader on a journey back in time and immerses them in country life. It is a story of prejudice, hardship, poverty, and what people will do to survive. Most of all it is a story of family and what people will do for love. A great read. Julie, VIC, 5 stars

The Whisky Widow is a meticulously crafted and well researched historical fiction novel which shares with its readers life in 1780’s Scotland. Not since Outlander have I enjoyed a book in this genre so much. Readers will come to know and love the inhabitants of Glasglen and enjoy the descriptions of whisky distilling which are the lifeblood of this community. It’s a story of intrigue, mystery and murder but also romance, family and community. I was swept into the past with Brooks’ glorious descriptions and fell in love with many of the cast of characters. A beautiful picture of a life and time many of us know little about. A novel with heart, bravery and a warmth that is as smooth as a dram of whisky. Michelle, QLD, 5 stars

i absolutely loved this book. I got so caught up in Greer and Fen’s story. So many amazing characters like Tori and the family. I wished it was longer and it continued on. I laughed and cried but just adored this book. Elizabeth, NSW, 5 stars

Set in the rugged beauty of the 1780s Scottish Highlands, The Whisky Widow by Karen Brooks is a bold and atmospheric tale that swirls with smoke, spirit, and survival. This isn’t just another romanticised Highland saga, it’s a gritty, grounded exploration of resilience, risk, and the women who held more than just households together. Brooks lifts the veil on the clandestine world of illicit whisky distilling, revealing it not only as a black-market lifeline but as a fierce act of cultural preservation. While the book captures the wind-swept poetry of the landscape and the sensual richness of whisky-making, it doesn’t shy away from the harsh realities: the violence, the hunger, the constant threat of losing everything. Told through a female lens, the story crackles with quiet defiance. This isn’t the tale of a woman who supports from the sidelines; Greer and her daughter Fen are heroines who work to rise above adversity, negotiating, fighting and loving with a ferocity only a woman can possess. Brooks doesn’t offer escapism; the Whisky Widow is an immersion into the Scottish highlands of 1780. You’ll smell the peat smoke, feel the bite of betrayal, and toast to the complex women whose stories history almost forgot. The Whisky Widow is a smart, layered read that lingers like a good drama – fiery, complex, and deeply satisfying. Cassie Sandison, QLD, 5 stars

This was such a suspenseful journey, to follow Greer as she led her deaf daughter to a new life in a time of famine and hardship. She finds family, loss, love, and courage to protect her new life, while dealing with an unjust government and unfair officials. Her bravery is what shines in this story, and I was obsessed until I finished. Kylie, QLD, 5 stars

1700’s Scotland a time of sly Whisky and seperate lives. Greer McAlister and her daughter Fen find themselves in a very changed life after the death of William who she thought was her husband. Travelling from Edinburgh to Montrose only to find what she thought was there was not. Greer and Fen now alone now to find their way thankfully to Tam Gordon this creates a whole new life for them. Already the struggle and shame is there as Greer finds out the truth and also how people react to Fen and her being Deaf. A story of twists and turns with added mystery. Such a great read for the historical fiction fans. Tianne, NSW, 5 stars

I thoroughly enjoyed reading this novel incorporating themes of love, distrust and the need to seek justice as members of a small Scottish village attempt to survive during difficult times. Set in Scotland between 1780 and 1784, The Whisky Widow by Karen Brooks describes a community bonding together for its survival. Meeting Tamhas Gorden provided Greer MacAlister and her daughter Fen the chance for a new life at Glasglen in the Scottish Highlands although Greer soon encountered prejudices regarding outsiders, especially Lowlanders, and realised that becoming accepted would not be an easy task. At Glasglen there was some farming and fishing, but the villagers mainly made their living from distilling and smuggling whisky. Although allowed to keep a small amount of whisky for their own consumption, a high excise was applied to the sale of whisky, hence the need for the smuggling operations. Life is hard but members of the village usually look after each other. However, the effects of the Clearances in the Highlands force many of the villagers to consider emigration as the only solution. Once again Karen Brooks has written an enthralling historical fiction novel. Vicki, VIC, 5 stars

Scotland, 1780. Greer MacAlister receives word that her husband, an excise man, has died. She and her daughter Fenella (Fen) travel from Edinburgh to Montrose to collect money owed to him. But the money is gone, and Greer and Fen are treated as outcasts. Desperate, Greer offers to work as housekeeper for Tam Gordon in the remote village he calls home. Illicit whisky making provides the means of survival for this small community, still feeling the effects of the Jacobite defeat at Culloden in 1746. The victorious, red-coated British patrol the area and make a difficult life more challenging. Initially viewed with suspicion, as lowland incomers, Greer and Fen become important members of the community. Part adventure, part romance, part tribute to a past now long gone, this is the story of courage, the challenges of family, and of justice. I am drawn into this story, with its smattering of Gaelic, with its mix of superstitious and supernatural beliefs and reminders of increasing hardship, resulting in exodus. Yes, I loved this story. It took me back into a lifestyle and history some of my ancestors were part of. Ms Brooks brings people and place to life. Jennifer, ACT, 5 stars

The Whisky Widow by Karen Brooks was a fabulous enthralling tale set in the Scottish Highlands during the 18th century. The attention to historical details and events was gripping and the main protagonist Greer MacAlister had a formidable presence throughout the book.The strength and endurance of the women folk was compelling to read and is often omitted in historical references. The daily hardships endured by the Scottish clans, the dangers, bravery, violence, interwoven with the mythical beliefs worked seamlessly throughout the novel. Absolutely loved this book from the first page to the befitting end. Karen Brooks never disappoints. Ilona, VIC, 5 stars

WOW what a story!! Packed with action, daring do, love. Absolutely loved it Gai, NSW, 5 stars

Another Karen Brooks triumph! The Whisky Widow draws you in to the highlands of Scotland in the 1780s and it does not let you go until the very last sentence. Greer MacAlister is left high and dry when her abomination of a husband dies. She now has to provide for herself and her daughter, Fen and through a set of unusual circumstances, they end up in the remote Scottish Highlands residing with a bunch of whiskey distillers and smugglers. As an ‘incomer’ – not from around there – Greer and Fen are initially shunned and mistrusted by the villagers. It takes every effort she can muster, to start to gain their trust and help them in their battles against the excise men who are after them. Greer has some allies in the village, and she has to rely on them to face one of the biggest challenges, not only of her life, but one that could determine the fate of the whole village. It’s a story where not only will you be immersed in the characters’ lives but the history of whisky and its symbolism and importance to the people will touch your heart. Lee, NSW, 5 stars

This was a great read – and a great way to spend a chilly weekend. A compelling story line, and a fabulous cast of characters. Like her earlier books, this one is meticulously researched, and brings 18th century Scotland to life. The dialogue and settings (two of my most wanted in a novel!) are believable and real. But thank goodness for the glossary of words at the end of the book. Some great plot twists and turns. Definitely not ‘an historical romance’ but plenty of love, and life and death, betrayal and friendship, and of course, whisky. So curl up with a wee dram and enjoy. Victoria, NSW, 5 stars

A heartrending novel of found family, fitting in and of course whisky! Greer and her daughter Fen find themselves ending up in the Scottish highlands, outsiders, and suspected of being informers to the dreaded excise men. They are not trusted and must fight an uphill battle to forge friendships and find a place to belong. They also end up caring just as much about the whisky which is the lifeblood of the village as any of the villagers! With some outrageous ideas and heaps of luck Greer plans to do whatever it takes to help the village and its people. On her journey she discovers that she has become one of them and that means more than anything. Atmospheric, thrilling and uplifting!! Kristy, NSW, 5 stars

Karen Brooks is to be congratulated for her extensive research. The reader is instantly transported to the misty Scottish highlands of 1780s by the descriptions of of the landscape and the Gaelic language interspersed throughout the text. A fabulous unputdownable book. Thank you for a thoroughly enjoyable read. Judy, QLD, 5 stars

I really enjoyed The Whisky Widow and once started, I didn’t want to put it down. It transported the reader to the Scottish Highlands in the 1780’s by the language, the people, and the atmosphere. From the outset the feisty Greer and her daughter Fen, faced hardship and disappointment but chose to see a setback as the reason to push forward and rebel. A wonderful rollicking read which had you laughing and crying as you held on for the ride. Lucia, VIC, 5 stars

The whisky widow was a fantastic read. Greer the hero of the story was such a strong woman, never letting adversary get her down, winning the admiration of the village. I could not put this book down, I just had to keep reading to get to the conclusion, it just got me sucked in. Very interesting read. Michelle, VIC, 5 stars

I’m totally immersed in the Scottish Highlands in the 1780s, living the life of Greer MacAlister and her daughter Fen in Karen Brook’s new historical novel The Whisky wife. I don’t want it to end but I can’t stop reading it. Vibrant characters, evocative atmospheres – history come alive. Deep research obviously underpins this novel, but it flows with strength of imagination and literary skills that readers have come to expect from Karen Brooks. I enjoy learning history through the lens of a believable well thought out piece of fiction and I trust the underlying resources that underpin this story of feisty Greer and her daughter, and the resilient community they encounter. Illicit whisky stills, cunning smugglers, suspicious excise officers and wary communities all set against the historical backdrop of the aftermath of the Battle of Colloden and the British occupation of Scotland. An absorbing and highly recommended read. Jennie, VIC, 5 stars

*The Whisky Widow* by Karen Brooks was an engrossing read that swept me away to the rugged Scottish Highlands of the late 1700s. From the very first pages, I was drawn into the world of Greer MacAlister, a newly widowed woman trying to rebuild her life in a community sustained by illegal whisky distilling. What I loved most was Greer’s transformation—from a grieving widow to a fierce and determined protector of her new home. Her resilience and grit, especially in the face of oppressive British law enforcement, made her a heroine I couldn’t help but root for. Brooks paints the historical backdrop with such richness that I could almost smell the smoke of the stills and feel the chill of the Highland wind. The story blends rebellion, survival, and female empowerment in a way that feels authentic rather than preachy. The details of whisky production and the culture surrounding it were especially fascinating and gave the novel a strong sense of place and purpose. This book stayed with me long after I finished it. If you’re a fan of historical fiction with a strong female lead and a setting that feels alive and untamed, *The Whisky Widow* is a story well worth your time. David, WA, 5 stars

An amazing read! The lead character is intelligent with plenty of grit who grabs life with both hands. Beautifully written with twists that keep you wondering how the story is going to unfold and a colourful portrayal of the lesser known history of whiskey smuggling in the highlands of Scotland. One of the best new books I have read this year! Frances, NSW, 5 stars

The Whisky Widow by Karen Brooks follows the life of Greer MacAlister after she is told that her husband, an excise man, has drowned. Along with her deaf daughter, Fen, she travels to the Scottish highlands to receive monies owed to her as his wife. However she is in for a huge shock. As the people take against her she is rescued by Tam Gordon and they are taken further into the highlands. As an incomer (outsider) she finds it hard to convince the villagers that she is on their side. When disaster strikes Greer proves her loyalty and Fen becomes a hero. This is an excellent tale of the conditions of highland villagers in the 1780s. The demands placed on villagers by the lairds and the British make life difficult. Survival is risky for all. Brooks clearly portrays life in the village and the importance of clan to the Scottish highlanders. The plot moves from success, to betrayal and disaster with the reader engrossed in the tale. With lots of intrigue, amusing events and family friction the life of the highlander is set out clearly for the reader. An informative and totally believable tale that is hard to put down. Will definitely be looking for more books by Karen Brooks. Annette, ACT, 5 stars

When Greer MacAllister learns of the death of her estranged husband William, a British excise officer, she journeys from Edinburgh to Montrose in the Scottish Highlands with their daughter Fen, hoping to claim his estate and wages and make a better life for them both. But when they arrive, Greer discovers William has committed one final act of betrayal against her, leaving them desperate and struggling to build a new life in this isolated area of the Highlands. Met with hostility by locals as an “incomer” and suspected of being an informant for excise officers looking for illegal whisky stills, they must fight to be accepted in their new community, a task made even more challenging by Fen’s deafness. But this is one battle Greer is determined to win, for herself and for her daughter … Written by Karen Brooks, author of best-seller The Good Wife of Bath and a number of other novels, The Whisky Widow is also likely to be popular. The historical plotline is interesting and believable, the characters are well-written and likeable, and the beautiful highland setting and description of the whisky-making process also add flavour and colour to this ultimately satisfying and enjoyable read. Carol, SA, 4 stars

Imagining the setting of this historical novel of the Scottish Highlands was a fantastic eye opener, especially following the lives a mother and daughter who to start with were frowned upon. Until the villages warmed up to Greer the mother when she put herself in danger to help with the whisky smuggling in the village. With the acceptance of the village the mother and daughter had a place to call home. Definitely a good historical novel Katen, QLD, 4 stars

I think any fan of historical fiction will love this book! Its setting and language immediately drew me in and made me feel like I was in the Scottish highlands myself. The whole atmosphere is like reading a cosy book while curled up on the couch on a rainy day, so reading this story was a great experience. The characters are definitely people you can root for, and I especially loved the relationship between the main character and her daughter. Because the setting and characters were written so well, this made the plot even more interesting and engaging so even someone who doesn’t usually read this genre will enjoy this book. Senara, QLD, 4 stars

A fabulous mix of history, intrigue and adventure Jacqui, NSW, 4 stars

This story was an absolute delight to experience. Greer is widowed and with her daughter she heads to the Highlands where she becomes a part of a community who distils and smuggles whisky. Given the time period, Greer’s very existence makes people suspicious, and she must fight for her place in the community and for the life she wants for her and her daughter. I was immersed in the story. I felt jubilation and equally found myself shedding a tear. I felt the prejudice, injustice, distrust and could feel the sneer on my face when people were…. uncooperative. I was taken in by the bravery of the protagonists (Greer and her daughter Fen) and their relationship with each other. My heart felt full when love was found. I marvelled at the need to succeed when it was a treacherous time to be a woman and a widow, let alone a widow of despised man. I was caught up in the adventure of taking on illicit whisky making, building a business, and smuggling. Please read this book. Aotea, QLD, 4 stars

I was very keen for this book, having adored a previous book by Brooks, “The wife of Bath”. This has a similarly inspiring feisty female narrator. Reading during a Melbourne winter, I marvelled at how precious we are about cold weather, compared to people living in the Highlands – some of them in caves !- two centuries ago. There were some particularly brutal scenes of combat and a vividly described birth, which also made me count my blessings. Fen’s Deafness led to an ingenious secret communication among the smugglers. Central to the story was the Highlanders’ attitude to “incomers” and their reluctance to speak or admit to understand English. This highlighted how humans are attuned to noticing and challenging difference, to our detriment. Heidi, VIC, 4 stars

In every glass of whisky lies a small act of rebellion… Part historical adventure, part romance. The Whisky Widow by Karen Brooks celebrates the art of illegal whisky distilling in the Scottish Highlands of 1780. A story brimming with mystery, suspense, emotion and intrigue, it follows Greer MacAlister and her young daughter Fen, who find themselves living in a remote whisky smuggling community in the heart of the Highlands. But living with a defiant community of Scottish Highlanders, who dislike outsiders, proves more difficult than Greer ever imagined. Greer is a smart and resilient woman though and she is able to trick excise officers away from the illegal stills with a courageous and daring act, and the community begins to warm to her. Finally she feels like her and Fen may have found a place to call home. But excise officers never give up and soon chaos reigns over this small community who wonder if their loved ones will ever make it home. With clever plot twists that had me turning the pages long into the night, Brooks has written a spirited (see what I did there) story of bravery, adventure, love and murder that vividly portrays the Scottish Highlands of the past and the lengths people went to in order to survive this beautifully hostile place. Emily, WA, 4 stars

Based in Scotland between 1780-1784, this novel at first was difficult to get into and I found the Gaelic made it harder to read. Once I got further into the novel I found it easier and a enjoyable read. Greer MacAlistar and her daughter Fen (who is deaf) leave their home in Edinburgh to travel to Montrose, Scotland to claim wages accrued by her late husband William, who was an excise officer and drowned at sea while on duty. His body was never recovered. To her dismay she is informed that the money is gone and William lead another life. They were treated as outcasts (incomers). Greer meets Tam Gordon who she begs to give her a job as a housekeeper. Tam lives in a remote village where he runs an illicit whiskey making business, to help his small community pay their debts to survive. Greer is not accepted at first into this community but works hard for her and Fen to be accepted and respected. This novel takes you on an adventure of romance, desperation, courage and many challenges. Renae, QLD, 4 stars

I loved reading about this part of Scotland’s history, told from a strong female point of view. The struggles she faced as a mother are identifiable and the writing was so descriptive, I felt transported to Scotland. Sarah, WA, 4 stars

The Whisky Widow by Karen Brooks is a great read. I was drawn in from the start and felt like I was right in amongst the characters and living the story with them. It is a story of the struggles of an estranged wife with a deaf daughter and making a new life for themselves. This is a story that will keep you wanting to read. Anna, TAS, 4 stars

A great read filled with rich believable characters of an era where they would do anything to survive under British occupation even when it involved smuggling and distilling of whiskey. The atmosphere of illegal stills, lowering clouds and the Scottish Highlands is a great backdrop. A story of how a widow and her daughter became an important part of a community that seemed to be always one step in front of the excise man. I thoroughly enjoyed it and should be added to your TBR pile, you won’ t be sorry. Chris, SA, 4 stars

Karen Brooks has done it again. She has cemented herself as a brilliant historical fiction writer. Her latest novel The Whisky Widow is set in the 1780’s Scottish Highlands and centres around Greer and her daughter Fen. This is as much a story about whisky as it is a story of rebellion, resilience, intriguing local customs and relationships. Trudy, SA, 4 stars

Greer is a very strong woman. Life has thrown her some tough situations. Her daughter Fen became deaf, her husband died, she had to leave her home to provide for her daughter. She ends up in a small village, where she is not trusted. She is a very straightforward person, almost unlikeable until someone explains to her that she holds the same prejudices against highlanders as they do about lowlanders. There is a lot of adventure happening, all because of whiskey and the excise. The characters are well written, I laughed out loud a few times at the things some said, mainly the local expressions. It is a story that succeeds in showing that while the men were always thought to be the main characters in history, women were ignored despite the fact they did the same work, if not more. Leanne, NSW, 4 stars

I love Karen Brooks books and the Whisky widow did not disappoint! Full of historical detail, suspense and lots of twists and turns I found this a highly enjoyable book! Jacinda, NSW, 4 stars

I really enjoyed The Whisky Widow by Karen Brooks and would give it a solid 4 stars. The story pulled me in right from the beginning with its vivid setting in 1780s Scotland and the strong, determined main character, Greer MacAlister. I loved how Greer stood her ground in a Highland village steeped in illegal whisky distilling —her courage and cleverness made her easy to root for. The historical detail was rich without being overwhelming, and I appreciated how Brooks wove in the cultural aftermath of Culloden and the impact of British rule on Highland life. The whisky-making element was fascinating and gave the story a unique edge. While there were a few slow moments, overall the pacing kept me engaged, and I found myself truly caring about the village, the characters, and Greer’s journey. There’s a subtle romance thread that added a nice touch without taking over the plot. This was a great mix of history, resilience, and a bit of intrigue. I’d definitely recommend it to anyone who loves historical fiction with a strong female lead and a story rooted in lesser-known parts of Scottish history. I’ll absolutely be reading more from Karen Brooks. Tiahne, QLD, 4 stars

This story breathes life into the untamed beauty and relentless hardships of the Scottish Highlands, wrapping its readers in the cadence of ancient tongues and the pulse of a bygone era. The narrative is woven with resilience and humanity, echoing the spirit of those who dared to dream and defy. The protagonist is a testament to the human ability to transform adversity into opportunity. Her journey is a personal triumph, and also reflects the strength found in unity and the courage to confront injustices. Every page is imbued with a vivid sense of place one can almost feel the chill of the mist and hear whispers carried by the wind. The language is descriptive, an ode to the land, its people, and their enduring legacy. The use of old Scottish and Gaelic terms enriches the narrative, adding authenticity and texture, while the glossary provides a deeper understanding of the culture and history embedded in the text. Through meticulous research, the author has crafted a tapestry where fiction meets historical truth, allowing the reader to walk the blurred line between the imagined and the real. This book is a tale of survival, ingenuity and a meditation on the bonds of friendship and the quiet strength found in solidarity. Rita, NSW, 4 stars

“In every glass of whisky lies a small act of rebellion…” The Whisky Widow by Karen Brooks is a bold, atmospheric historical novel set in the 1780 Scottish Highlands—a land still bearing the wounds of Culloden and simmering under British rule. When Greer MacAlister’s cruel husband dies, she and her daughter Fen find themselves in a remote village where whisky smuggling isn’t just tradition—it’s survival. Thrust into this world of danger, defiance, and illicit distilling, Greer must win the villagers’ trust and protect her child, all while navigating the ever-present threat of the excise men. But she’s no shrinking violet. Brave, intelligent, and resourceful, Greer steps into her power one daring act at a time. Brooks masterfully blends history, adventure, and heart. This is a love letter to the Highlands and to whisky itself—smoky, complex, and layered with meaning. Themes of motherhood, autonomy, and rebellion ripple through the pages, giving the story both heat and heart. I was completely swept up in the vivid setting and the strength of Greer’s spirit. Like the finest dram, I savoured this story slowly—and felt its fire long after the final sip. Slàinte mhath! Liisa, QLD, 4 stars

The Whisky Widow was everything you would expect for a story set in the Scottish Highlands. Superstition, steadfast loyalty, adventure and love, this story had it all. I really enjoyed the story being told through the lens of the whisky trade. It was a real eye opener to understand the human stories behind the “smuggling.” A thoroughly enjoyable read. Alice, NSW, 4 stars

This vibrant historical novel set in the Scottish Highlands during the 1780s weaves together themes of bravery, resilience. mystery and hardship. The protagonist navigates personal tragedy and societal expectations to preserve her late husband’s distillery. It was evident this novel was well-researched, with such detailed nuances carefully described of the distillery process. Fast-paced, full of intrigue and suspense I very much enjoyed this novel. I learnt so much about the Scottish Highlands during this era and whiskey distilleries and all the richer from reading it. Justine, NSW, 4 stars

I ran away with a historical romance only to smack solidly into a murder mystery—and I couldn’t be more grateful. Greer is an oustanding heroine with a sharp mind and kind heart who rises to every challenge. Balancing grit with grace, the story simmers with slow-burn romance, rich historical detail, delightful, loveable characters all in a small Scottish Glen impossible to forget. Tanya, SA, 4 stars

It is a rollicking tale written in a Gaelic brogue style to suit the setting as Brooks tends to do with her novels. It reveals one woman’s strength in the face of desertion, betrayal and being a social outcast with a deaf daughter. They learn not only to survive in the Scottish highlands, but become part of their community and thrive socially and in business. A great read of never giving up despite adversity and believing in your strengths. A wonderful read. Hirell, NSW, 4 stars

I really enjoyed this book, I love Scotland so the setting was perfect. I loved learning more about whisky, and found the story was hard to put down. Jessica, NSW, 4 stars

I’m in two minds on this book. It’s a very interesting period of history and the research the author has done really shows with a lot of excellent, visceral detail. It’s very slow to start which is a good thing, allowing it to take time to properly establish the characters and set the scene. When the action really sets in is around page 300 which makes for a crazy mad dash to fit in all the plot before the end. Points off also for the glossary which omits about 75% of the words I tried to look up! Still I was definitely intrigued and interested in spending time with Greer and Fen and I enjoyed the latter half of the book immensely. Richard, VIC, 3 stars

This book is definitely character driven where you will fall in love with Greer and her daughter, Fen. Greer has grit and determination despite some very hard odds and you’ll be rooting for her – in life and love. Stacey, WA, 3 stars

The Whiskey Widow is historical fiction at its most detailed. Such a detailed journey back to village life the 1780s in the Scottish Highlands, where the conflicts with British excise officers, lairds and the lowlanders added to the trials and tribulations of a harsh lifestyle. Karen Brooks gives us Greer McAlister, a woman with tenacity and grit, trying to find life for herself and her deaf daughter Fen, inn a place where her deceased husband had forgotten all about her. This is just as much about her new life in the highlands as it was about highland village lifers in the 1780s where survival for anyone is not without danger from people let alone the elements. Rebellion was a central theme for the highlander as it was for Greer: she would find anything that stood in her way, including getting her daughter into a local school, and being able to corral the menu workers who were rebuilding Tam Gordon’s home to work with her instead of against her. She became the ’smuggler’s wife who made a pact with the devil – the exciseman who … would see her husband handed for murder.” The pacing moves slower in the first third than in the rest of the book, and once it gains momentum, it becomes a beguiling escapade full of wry wit, perils and twists in one of the hardest landscapes in the late 1700s. Marlene, NSW, 3 stars

Buy a copy of The Whisky Widow here.